*FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. Marcion was critical in the emergence of the Catholic Church. Harnack presents Marcion’s historical significance. Adolf Harnack () was a German theologian, scholar and historian. on Marcion called Marcion, das Evangelium vom fremden Gott (Marcion and the . The outlines of Harnack’s landmark monograph on Marcion are well known from summaries and discussions of it as well as through the German original. But it is.

Author: Volkis Tojasida
Country: Laos
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Sex
Published (Last): 26 June 2015
Pages: 424
PDF File Size: 7.92 Mb
ePub File Size: 3.30 Mb
ISBN: 194-4-53088-907-1
Downloads: 30963
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Vogor

Retrieved from ” https: And yet this innovation was partly caused by a religious conviction, the origin of which must be sought not in heathenism, but on Old Testament and Christian soil. He had many more gripes as well, but those four are the gist of it. Markus Dialogue II, 5: Any more than it is anti-Hindu to draw distinctions between the Christian and Vedanta God-concepts?

And think of the Johannine retrojection of the quarrels and excommunications of his own day into the story of Jesus, as Louis Martyn has demonstrated History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel.

He demonstrated the contradictions between the Old Testament and the Gospel in a voluminous work the antithesis. The older attempts to restore the Marcionite Haranck and Apostolicum have been antiquated by Zahn’s Kanonsgeschichte, 1. But the strict asceticism hanack Marcion demanded as a Christian, could have had no motive, without the Greek assumption of a metaphysical contrast of flesh and Spirit, which in fact harnac, also apparently the doctrine of Paul.

They can’t bear the idea that the miracles happened. Christ, therefore, rescued from the underworld, not the righteous men of the Old Testament Iren. For this very reason, he could not help actually making the good God the judge, though in theory he rejected the idea, in order not to measure the will and acts of God by a human standard.

For this task he did harrnack appeal to a divine revelation, any special instruction, nor to a pneumatic assistance [ He produced many religious publications marcio to in which he is sometimes credited as Adolf Harnack. The just god appears at the end of history, not as an independent being, hostile to the good God, but as one subordinate to him, 24 so that some scholars, such as Neander, have attempted to claim for Marcion a doctrine of one principle, and to deny that he ever held the complete independence of the creator of the world, the creator of the world being simply an angel of the good God.


His disciples who had theoretical interests in the matter, no doubt noted the contradictions. Nuh marked it as to-read Nov 16, Withney Just rated it it was amazing Dec 07, Published by Boston, Little We may venture to say no. Marcion and the New Testament: Facebook Twitter Email Print. His acute sorting out of the similarities and differences between Marcionism and Gnosticism show that Marcion was by no means a Gnostic, nor even an heir of Gnosticism.

Adolf von Harnack

The Man and His Faith. In point of fact, Marcion seems to have given such a turn to marciin good God’s attributes of love, and incapability of wrath, as to make Him the apathetic, infinitely exalted Being, free from all affections.

The idea of a deliverance of all men, which seems to follow from his doctrine of boundless grace, was quite foreign to him. Of course, had Marcion read Feyerabend, this wouldn’t have stopped him it didn’t anyway! Must it not have seemed an inconceivable inconsistency, if he had clung to the special national relation of Christianity to the Jewish people, and if he had taught a view of history in which for paedagogic reasons indeed, the Father of mercies and God of all marcioj had appeared as one so entirely different?

Pretty dry but fills you in on all there is about this heretical, early Christian branch. Jennifer Chou marked it as to-read Dec 14, Hahn Regimonti, has attempted to restore the Antitheses. Alex Moma marked it as harnacck Aug 31, Perhaps it is the roots only of these Gnostic reinterpretations of established mythemes that we ought to be tracing, not the whole mythos.

Just finished this one. Late 19th- and early 20th-century theologian Adolf von Harnackin agreement with the traditional account of Marcion as revisionist, theorized that Marcion believed there could marckon only one true gospel, all others being fabrications by pro-Jewish elements, determined to sustain worship of Yahweh ; and that the true gospel was given directly to Paul the Apostle by Christ himself, but was later corrupted by those same elements who mmarcion corrupted the Mafcion epistles.


Adolf Harnack. Marcion: Das Evangelium vom fremden Gott

Christ called to himself the weary and heavy laden, 21 and proclaimed to them that he would deliver them from the fetters of their lord and from the world. Marilynn Hughes rated it it was amazing Apr 14, Perhaps through those lenses we might view the exegesis of the Alien God as no less unbecoming an elaboration of scripture than most of us now consider the Triune God.

In this conviction he founded a Church: Robert marked it as to-read Sep 27, The idea that the Marcionite version of the epistles of Paul pre-dated the conventional version did not fit in well with Harnack’s view of history; he was firmly convinced that the epistles of Polycarp and Ignatius were genuine, and thus believed that Catholic copies of the epistles of Paul pre-dated Marcion. Epiphanius [ PanarionBook I, part 42, verse It was only after the failure of his attempts hsrnack reform that he founded churches of his own, in which brotherly equality, freedom from all ceremonies, and strict evangelical discipline were to rule.

Harnack on Marcion

But in doing so they were unconsciously serving his purpose, for his death was the price by which the God of love purchased men from the uarnack of the world. He couldn’t countenance the God of the Old Testament, and he couldn’t bear the Jewishness marcioh the new faith.

Books by Adolf von Harnack. Zahn, die Dialoge des Adamantius in the Ztschr. Martyrdom was enjoined; and from the fact that they were “palaipwoi kai misoumenoi” in the world, the members were to know that they were disciples of Christ.

Very frequently the Prophet tells forth “secret histories” of the biblical Patriarchs hsrnack which their exploits mirror those of Muhammad himself in mirror-fashion.

I don’t think I’d read it again but I’ll keep it for reference. Church Fathers wrote, and the majority of modern scholars agree, [2] [3] that Marcion edited Luke to fit his own theologyMarcionism.