Sept. · · · · · © Hermann Detering. Powered by WordPress | Theme: Graphy von Themegraphy. René Salm has so far compiled 26 web pages addressing Hermann Detering’s “ new” argument for Christian origins involving influences from. In the Fall issue of The Journal of Higher Criticism, an author named Herman Detering offers an item titled The Falsified Paul. The dedication tells the story.
|Published (Last):||22 January 2013|
|PDF File Size:||13.53 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||10.38 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
It argues that Christianity emerged from a gnostic substratum, and that the figure Jesus of Nazareth and the New Testament gospels are second century CE developments.
English Choose a language for shopping. From Paul of the Legends to the Historical Paul.
We need also not be detained by Detering’s extended efforts to equate Paul with Simon Magus, for his argument assumes that he has priorly proven his case. Ein und derselbe Mond spiegelt sich In allen Wassern. That’s simple, says Detering: From Acts to the Pauline Writings.
I feel confident that those who don’t would be able to dismiss Detering’s approach.
Neil, this is actually rather useful. Also, if Paul has been told that he had a job to do by the Risen Jesus, it hardly makes sense for him to immediately go back home where he will likely be executed or imprisoned.
Hermann Detering and Robert M. Price |
Help us improve our Author Pages by updating your bibliography and submitting a new or current image and biography. It is not enough to say that Plutarch, for example, was “open to all religious movements” of his time and then stand back amazed that Paul is not mentioned hermamn this. Views Read Edit View history. However, he is also likely counting on readers not knowing this. Es steht das Nichts in der Mandel.
Your email address will not be published. According to Detering, the switch to a plural “we” does not agree with the singular Paul uses of himself in 1: This simply fails to account for reporting methods used in this period; see here.
Their writings are strictly polemical and so it would have been better to rely on “gnostic” tractates such as the Gospel of Phillip instead; especially in relation to the notion of the “bridal chamber” in conjunction with the imitation of cosmic syzygies.
Detering errs regarding 1 Cor. Slain by the gentiles 5. Thus, the 24 posts they have already been drafted should take 3—6 months to upload.
Similar authors to follow
Simon was the “standing, stable, germann one” alluding to the timeless unchanging divine realm. A Final Open Question. Wie ich inzwischen bemerkt habe, sind dem Programm allerdings gewisse Grenzen gesetzt. Detering remarks almost at once upon what he finds to be the oddity of Paul saying so little about Jesus.
One the god of the Old Cetering, whose concern is rightegiousness. Fascinating detective work; Bizarre conclusion An absolutely fascinating look at why certain scholars a minority of them, but still claim that none of Paul’s letters are authentic In terms of arguing for ahistoricity, Detering spends more time objecting to how commentators add drama to the scene with their own colorful descriptions than he does actually addressing the narrative.
Available for download now. Dec 27, Peter Stanbridge rated it it was amazing. He than proposes that the real Paul was one and the same with the person of Simon Magus. Thompson Visions William Wrede. Der Anlass mag kirchenjahresbedingt wechseln, die Deterring der Kirchenoberen lautet seit ein paar Jahren immer gleich: Be the first to ask a deteribg about The Fabricated Paul. A gnostic messianic community later appeared alongside the Jewish-Christian messianic community.
ComiXology Thousands of Digital Comics. Und nun soviel Licht. Why this ought to be an issue is not explained. Oct 30, Yimmy rated it really liked it Shelves: This series of posts has the following goals: Only 2 left in stock – order soon.
Amazon Renewed Refurbished products with a warranty. Notify me of new posts by email. Detering needs to show that letter openings as a whole lacked “pretense” whatever that is supposed to mean; it needs to be defined and then also show that in the specific case of Galatians, this deering is unwarranted.
The best freedom would be to jestison the whole idea of a theistic god.
Hermann Detering, The Dutch Radical Approach to the Pauline Epistles
From Baur to Bauer. Detering does a disservice if he believes he can assume this as a bedrock of his thesis and ignore contrary arguments.
Simon the Leper and Paul’s Sickness. Learn more at Author Central. To operate against a strong consensus position — in this case, one which sees Paul as at least the author of seven of 13 letters in the NT, if not more — requires a great deal of work.